Welcome to Flightinfo.com

  • Register now and join the discussion
  • Friendliest aviation Ccmmunity on the web
  • Modern site for PC's, Phones, Tablets - no 3rd party apps required
  • Ask questions, help others, promote aviation
  • Share the passion for aviation
  • Invite everyone to Flightinfo.com and let's have fun

FMS warning for non-aligned takeoff?

Welcome to Flightinfo.com

  • Register now and join the discussion
  • Modern secure site, no 3rd party apps required
  • Invite your friends
  • Share the passion of aviation
  • Friendliest aviation community on the web
GCD said:
It's technique and procedure at a lot of carriers to set the heading bug to the runway heading as soon as it is assigned or advised on the ATIS. The runway checks then should include scanning instruments for the proper heading alignment on all heading indicators and heading bugs.

No person is perfect or makes a perfect plan.

You're right. There are many good plans, yet no perfect ones. Nobody's perfect either, and yet our imperfections vary.

The goal, however, remains the same...safety. Uneventful flights. We're given many aids, procedures, rules, agencies, standards, and information at our disposal to try and mitigate and/or overcome failures, distractions, complacency, fatigue, and ignorance to achieve this. Despite them, we don't always.

But that doesn't change the fact that ultimately, it's up to us...the pilots. No matter what the atmosphere or level of technology/equipment/information at our disposal, being the "final authority" means we can stop the Show entirely if we decide we don't like what's happening or our level of support. Everyone entrusting us with thier lives expects this. It's what a guy sitting in his farmhouse off the end of a runway expects. These are completely reasonable expectations.

Imperfect people we may be, but continually striving for perfection while performing our Lives-at-stake task is the foundation of being a professional.

Plans, SOP's, etc. are essentially defensive measures....designed by imperfect people as well. Things like T/O Config and Gear horns are last-ditch defenses engineered to wake-up someone asleep at his post. Since we aren't clones with identical, inherent succeptabilities or weaknesses and no One-sized-SOP-fits-all, it's advisable to at least mentally supplement them with those targeting our own personal weaknesses and/or holes found in whichever SOP's you're working with.

Defensive measures only work if you are PROactive in applying them. Being proactive equates to vigilance, and professionalism demands that if we aren't supplied them, we seek out, find, and use whatever tools we personally need to maintain it. Different things work for different people.

Working in an Third Worldly environment where frequently you can't count on anything (signage, lights, good/unobstructed runways, ATC, NOTAMS, uncontaminated fuel, a common language, security, good wx info, etc.) only brings into sharper focus how important vigilance is. But Third or First world environment differences don't change "Flying is flying" basics. Vigilance is a Basic.

I find myself reverting to the most basic of basic things at certain trip-points that occur every flight, regardless of location or conditions, as a defence against the hassles, distractions, and sub-standard conditions myself and the other crew might find ourselves immersed in. These are the 2 points/things I do...not that anyone else might give a rat's a$$...

Before asking for the Engine Start checklist I silently admonish myself with the old expression to "Screw your flying head on". I actually get a mental picture of unscrewing my head and threading on a new one (no kidding, it kind of looks like the inflatable autopilot's from the movie Airplane).

I may have been told this expression in the past after screwing up. Or maybe I read it somewhere. I honestly can't remember but for some odd reason that one expression/cliche' has stuck with me, and for me it goes a long way to banish...at least in my conciousness...all the outside-world stuff/distractions/hassles/worries leading up to when we're ready to begin spinning things. Gaining that attitude helps me adhere to SOP's, be aware, and increase my vigilance to a higher level no matter what it was before.

The other trip-point thingy I do is during the last few heartbeats before pushing up the thrust levers. I still do them because the first guy I ever flew jets with told me they were still "always real f***in' 'pohtnt" (that's redneck-ese for "Important")...referring to and reinforcing the notion that you check "killer items" no matter what checklists you'd done, what airplane you're flying, or which airport you're at. He may have off-handedly made it up because I was a newbie...I don't know..but it was that reinforcement of what I'd learned before, despite the fact that I was now "jet flying" and the items tweaked a bit accordingly, that left an impact I suppose. "Always real f-in 'pohtnt", or "ARFP", unlike our other aviation acronyms, is also so hard to say it struck me as very funny at the time.

If I try to remember more than 2 technical things (out of how many possible?) while swinging a golf club the ball is going into the woods. It's why I still silently use that guy's ARFP Checklist. It's short and easy, within my limitations, and I will ALWAYS be at that "just before spooling moment" if I'm taking something into the air.

A..irframe clean and anti-ice.

R...unway....starting inside with compass matching runway heading and clearance to include the runway itself being unobstructed and unthreatened as far as you can see. Contamination considered.

F..laps.

P..erformance...meeting it for that take-off and departure, with all of the above (A,R, and F) factored in and set.

Sure the way I remember those items is silly, but I've done that guy's unpronouncable ARFP checklist from O'hare to KL and Moscow to Cape Town (and too many crapholes in between) for over 2 decades just before pushing the thrust levers up. For me it's like a bad song you can't keep from popping into your head at certain moments, you know? And the more stressful, fatiguing, distracting, and unfamiliar things are, it seems to pop up more loudly and more often. It's saved my a$$ a time or two though, when my pilots head wasn't screwed completely on.

The point is, find something that works for you and do it every time no matter what else happens. Rely on yourself for the Basics, not on PFM boxes.
 
Last edited:
Baby Cakes said:
There is no such capability today in aircraft FMS's.

Yes there is, but until now, airlines have shunned the extra cost.

Honeywell offers the Runway Awareness and Advisory System (RAAS) as a software add-on to existing EGPWS systems. Among other things, it gives you an aural warning if you take off on a runway that is too short for your aircraft. It would have prevented this accident, but it's a $12,000 option that most airlines do not choose to add (and I'm not sure if it's only available on Honeywell EGPWS boxes- the CRJ has Collins avionics).

Maybe this system will now be mandated for Part 121 air carriers- another regulation that is written in blood.
 
Those runway's at LEX are easy to confuse. I watched a mainline DL 73 line up on 26 and I have almost done it myself. Early morning lights on 26...yea I can see how it would happen.
 
EagleRJ said:
Yes there is, but until now, airlines have shunned the extra cost.

Honeywell offers the Runway Awareness and Advisory System (RAAS) as a software add-on to existing EGPWS systems. Among other things, it gives you an aural warning if you take off on a runway that is too short for your aircraft. It would have prevented this accident, but it's a $12,000 option that most airlines do not choose to add (and I'm not sure if it's only available on Honeywell EGPWS boxes- the CRJ has Collins avionics).

Maybe this system will now be mandated for Part 121 air carriers- another regulation that is written in blood.

Where do you draw the line? We are pilots here people, if you mess up you pay the consequences (unfortunately the passengers do to) This should be an impetus for every pilot to slow... down...and... think. There is so much automation in the cockpit, pilots are losing basic skills.
 
Regul8r said:
There is so much automation in the cockpit, pilots are losing basic skills.

Bingo. But what do you think the next FAA mandate will be? More computers or software to have distracting us.
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by VABB
It's called your eyeballs. Use them to cross-check your heading indication and also to take a look at the moving map.

We need less automation and more common sense.



There's alot of truth in the above.... However, mistakes happen and they will continue to happen... There are systems that can prevent accidents like yesterday from happening... What was the guy in the tower doing? I realize its not there job to "babysit" or to watch over what we do, but Isn't this a team effort...ie.. ATC and Pilots working together? JMO. Anyhow what I was getting at is the fact that COMPLACENTCY kills... When we as pilots loose touch with all the things that they beat into us during training... ie.. use checklist, dont be in a hurry, situational awareness, etc... When we get away from all that, mistakes happen. Let this be a lesson to all of us... I bet everyone out there after yesterday is looking at their HSI before they take off... Especially at night... Come on be honest.. You know you have. This is all just my opinion of course. I sincerely hope I have not offended anyone in anyway... Thoughts and prayers to everyone who has lost from the accident.. Thoughts and prayers to everyone who works at Comair. And finally thoughts and prayers to all of us who day to day get in the cockpit to make a living. Lets do our best to never become complacent when our hands are on the yoke and throttles..
 
Not that it is a cure all to this potential problem but just briefing how you are going to taxi out to the runway helps! I am an FO and I try to pay attention to the taxi diagram and where we are going at all times. I have caught captains making taxi mistakes, not wrong runway mind you, and I know I will make the same mistakes when I upgrade.

I have heard from quite a few captains that some of their FO's just sit there and stare out the window. They do not pay attention to what is going on. This job requires professionalism and it requires vigilance at all times. If you can do neither you need to quit. The Comair crash was an experienced crew and I hope at some point we will all learn the factual accounts of what happened.

I also like the set the heading bug to the assigned runway before taxi and/or the CDI needle.
 
Interesting.

BigShotXJTdrvr said:
Those who have taxied to 22 at LEX at night know how easy it is to want to just turn left and line up on 26.

Just about every time I've been there under similar conditions, I have had to fight that natural tendency, read the signs and go real slow around that whole cocked-up hold line/runway cross/left turn/2nd hold line/2nd runway area. It is so easy to see how this could happen. I haven't been there in a while, but I hear there is contruction and as a result it's currently even MORE confusing than usual. This really could have been any of us.[/quote]

Funny...

I'm wondering if you'd said the same with 9E or Mesa, or Jetstream accident. Interesting how our sentiments change when the accident is caused by sheer mistakes of so-called 'experienced' pilots compared to less experienced pilots that 9E, Mesa, etc., are accused of hiring.

Why can't we just say that it was a pilot's error and and nothing else. Yep, I can see 'spin-zone' at maximum power.

Sad indeed what has happened, but sad also how everyone has a different perspective. F/O 44 (hired 3/99), Captain, 35 (hired 11/99), wow...now you can't point a finger at so-called low-experience...so, let's just start feeling empathy.

Almost comical!
 
Empathy is certainly called for. Who of us has not been distracted if not in an aircraft, how about your car or boat, etc.? How many remember setting the heading bug and checking the compass before putting the coals to the old 172 or whatever? How many times have you driven out of your neighborhood and cannot remember if you stopped at the stopped sign.
Pilots are human and sometime stumble or lose focus but for those who think machines could do all this, remember humans made the machines.
We all have those Aw Sh-- moments--just most of the time we make it out and learn something from it. In those cases when we do not make it out, well hopefully others will learn.
 
CatYaaak said:
You're right. There are many good plans, yet no perfect ones. Nobody's perfect either, and yet our imperfections vary.

The goal, however, remains the same...safety. Uneventful flights. We're given many aids, procedures, rules, agencies, standards, and information at our disposal to try and mitigate and/or overcome failures, distractions, complacency, fatigue, and ignorance to achieve this. Despite them, we don't always.

But that doesn't change the fact that ultimately, it's up to us...the pilots. No matter what the atmosphere or level of technology/equipment/information at our disposal, being the "final authority" means we can stop the Show entirely if we decide we don't like what's happening or our level of support. Everyone entrusting us with thier lives expects this. It's what a guy sitting in his farmhouse off the end of a runway expects. These are completely reasonable expectations.

Imperfect people we may be, but continually striving for perfection while performing our Lives-at-stake task is the foundation of being a professional.

Plans, SOP's, etc. are essentially defensive measures....designed by imperfect people as well. Things like T/O Config and Gear horns are last-ditch defenses engineered to wake-up someone asleep at his post. Since we aren't clones with identical, inherent succeptabilities or weaknesses and no One-sized-SOP-fits-all, it's advisable to at least mentally supplement them with those targeting our own personal weaknesses and/or holes found in whichever SOP's you're working with.

Defensive measures only work if you are PROactive in applying them. Being proactive equates to vigilance, and professionalism demands that if we aren't supplied them, we seek out, find, and use whatever tools we personally need to maintain it. Different things work for different people.

Working in an Third Worldly environment where frequently you can't count on anything (signage, lights, good/unobstructed runways, ATC, NOTAMS, uncontaminated fuel, a common language, security, good wx info, etc.) only brings into sharper focus how important vigilance is. But Third or First world environment differences don't change "Flying is flying" basics. Vigilance is a Basic.

I find myself reverting to the most basic of basic things at certain trip-points that occur every flight, regardless of location or conditions, as a defence against the hassles, distractions, and sub-standard conditions myself and the other crew might find ourselves immersed in. These are the 2 points/things I do...not that anyone else might give a rat's a$$...

Before asking for the Engine Start checklist I silently admonish myself with the old expression to "Screw your flying head on". I actually get a mental picture of unscrewing my head and threading on a new one (no kidding, it kind of looks like the inflatable autopilot's from the movie Airplane).

I may have been told this expression in the past after screwing up. Or maybe I read it somewhere. I honestly can't remember but for some odd reason that one expression/cliche' has stuck with me, and for me it goes a long way to banish...at least in my conciousness...all the outside-world stuff/distractions/hassles/worries leading up to when we're ready to begin spinning things. Gaining that attitude helps me adhere to SOP's, be aware, and increase my vigilance to a higher level no matter what it was before.

The other trip-point thingy I do is during the last few heartbeats before pushing up the thrust levers. I still do them because the first guy I ever flew jets with told me they were still "always real f***in' 'pohtnt" (that's redneck-ese for "Important")...referring to and reinforcing the notion that you check "killer items" no matter what checklists you'd done, what airplane you're flying, or which airport you're at. He may have off-handedly made it up because I was a newbie...I don't know..but it was that reinforcement of what I'd learned before, despite the fact that I was now "jet flying" and the items tweaked a bit accordingly, that left an impact I suppose. "Always real f-in 'pohtnt", or "ARFP", unlike our other aviation acronyms, is also so hard to say it struck me as very funny at the time.

If I try to remember more than 2 technical things (out of how many possible?) while swinging a golf club the ball is going into the woods. It's why I still silently use that guy's ARFP Checklist. It's short and easy, within my limitations, and I will ALWAYS be at that "just before spooling moment" if I'm taking something into the air.

A..irframe clean and anti-ice.

R...unway....starting inside with compass matching runway heading and clearance to include the runway itself being unobstructed and unthreatened as far as you can see. Contamination considered.

F..laps.

P..erformance...meeting it for that take-off and departure, with all of the above (A,R, and F) factored in and set.

Sure the way I remember those items is silly, but I've done that guy's unpronouncable ARFP checklist from O'hare to KL and Moscow to Cape Town (and too many crapholes in between) for over 2 decades just before pushing the thrust levers up. For me it's like a bad song you can't keep from popping into your head at certain moments, you know? And the more stressful, fatiguing, distracting, and unfamiliar things are, it seems to pop up more loudly and more often. It's saved my a$$ a time or two though, when my pilots head wasn't screwed completely on.

The point is, find something that works for you and do it every time no matter what else happens. Rely on yourself for the Basics, not on PFM boxes.

Excellent post. I am not ashamed to admit I learned something here. But then agian, if you ever stop learning...

ARFP... Gonna get added to my mental "go" list. Its a nice memory device.
 

Latest resources

Back
Top