Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I think it's a pretty weak excuse to refuse the airplane just because of an autopilot. If you're too fatigued to hand fly, you're too fatigued for an engine failure, flap malfunction... whatever, if the A/P is working. You're out of RVSM, so flying at the lower altitudes is easier, and safer. I'm also presuming there's still a flight director and a first officer.
It is not unsafe to hand fly a jet or any other aircraft, I don't care what the weather or the FOs experience is. It's been done for generations. If you've ever flown a Metro, Jetstream or B1900 you'd know how to deal with it on a daily basis.
Granted, I wasn't there and not privy to all the info. I've called in fatigued myself, greatly angering the company and inconveniencing the passengers. I was never called on the carpet. I've never called in fatigued or refused an aircraft just to convenience me.
And you are the guy that doesn't know that there is a difference between legal and safe. You go get em John Wayne.
And you are the guy that doesn't know that there is a difference between legal and safe. You go get em John Wayne.
Ok, I'll bite. Define safe.
Actually, I do. Both times I fatigued, once in Canada, the second in the U.K. were both legal, could have easily "shown" to be legal, but they weren't safe.
Hand flying is not Cowboy flying. It's flying. All that time in the "Deisel Navajo" must have been unsafe. Is that what you're saying? Again, there are two pilots in the cockpit. You can take turns turning on the same flight. Is there not two FD on a "Hoser Jet?" If so, is there a CWS function with the A/P? I'd be a little scared to leave the cockpit to pee if you were flying. Might end up like that Indian carrier. Or the Japanese pilot....
Ouch.One made it 410
Maybe you could expand on what you said below.
Granted, I wasn't there and not privy to all the info
One made it 410
OK, I will.
1. Autopilot defered
Not in and of itself a refusal to fly. As you said there are other factors, such as destination, alternate and enroute WX, RVSM and fuel requirements. Any other write ups? Does the FD work? Above 10,000 the FO flies.
2. Green FO (second flight off O.E.)
Depends. Have I flown with him/her before? What was his/her experience prior to employment? This also depends on what one thinks of the training department. Generally speaking this would be last on my list unless he's incompetent.
3. Flying MEM to BOS
Also depends. What leg of the day? How's the day going so far? Dest./Alt. WX? As long as it's not on an OTS.
4. Thunderstorms along the route and up and down the Eastern Seaboard.
Again, depends. Isolate, scattered, systemic, embedded, destination, alternate? This could be number 2, depending on the "quality" of the FO. Lots of variables here, but it depends on the radar, satellite and forecasts. Granted, evening operations in one of the NYNJPA (Sewark, La Garbage or the Swamp) airports might change my mind.
I also said this:
Calling in fatigued and bragging about it is unseemly and unprofessional. Saying or thinking that you "stuck it to the man" is counter-productive and solves nothing. Now, if there are multiple deferrals adding to the complexity, this also changes things. Been there, done that, and pushed back, but I had a case with multiple factors every time.